Should Traditional Catholics Attend the "Indult" Mass?
The Society of Saint Pius X could never profit by Rome's Indult, first because of the conditions attached to it, and, in particular, that of acknowledging the "doctrinal and juridical" value of the Novus Ordo Missae which is impossible and second, but more fundamentally, because such acceptance of the Indult would amount to saying that the Church had lawfully suppressed the traditional Latin Mass, which is certainly not the case. But other priests have profited by it, some jumping at the chance to say the traditional Latin Mass, others only because requested by their Bishop, and the odd one or two who would always say the traditional Latin Mass anyway but have accepted to do so under the auspices of the Indult for "pastoral reasons".
Can We attend Their Masses?
If we have to agree to the doctrinal and juridical value of the Novus Ordo, then NO, for we cannot do evil that good may ensue. This condition may not be presented explicitly, but by implication, such as:
This brings up the whole context of the Indult Mass, it is:
- by a priest who celebrates the Novus Ordo on other days of the week or at other times;
- using Hosts consecrated at a Novus Ordo Missae;
- or with communion in the hand;
- new lectionaries, Mass facing the people, etc;
- by a priest who was ordained in the New Rite;
- by sermons that are modernist in inspiration (much to be feared if the celebrant habitually says the Novus Ordo Missae);
- by offering only the revised forms of the other sacraments, eg. penance.
- a ploy to keep people away from the Society of Saint Pius X (for many Bishops allow only where there is a Society of Saint Pius X Mass Centre);
- intended only for those who feel attached to the traditional Latin Mass but nevertheless accept the doctrinal rectitude and juridical right of the Novus Ordo Missae, Vatican II, and all official orientations corresponding to these.
Therefore, attending [the indult Mass] because of the Priest's words or fellow Mass-goers' pressure or because of the need to pander to the local Bishop just to have it inevitably pushes one to keep quiet on "diverse issues" and, distance oneself from those who do not keep quiet, ie. it pushes one to join the ranks of those who are destroying the Church. This one cannot do. The Indult Mass is therefore not for traditional Catholics.
NB: The above also applies to Moto Proprio Masses.
Extract from "Most Asked Questions about the Society of Saint Pius X", printed by the Angelus Press, USA, 1997.